Sunday, February 19, 2012

What is the real story behind this article?  

Stay two metres away from pets, judge orders rancher

A Knutsford rancher has been banned from being within two metres of “any animal or bird” after concerns were raised by the SPCA about her involvement in the sale of a Great Dane puppy.

 If Carole Haughton goes to a friend’s house and a dog shows up at the door, she must back away, the woman was told Monday. She can only be within two metres of a pet if it passes by with someone on a public street.

Provincial court judge Stella Frame made the new order after Haughton appeared at the Kamloops courthouse with defence lawyer Ken Walker to turn herself in.

A warrant had been issued for the woman’s arrest last Nov. 22 after concerns she had breached her bail by selling a puppy to a Richmond man.

Lawyer Ken Walker told the court the RCMP investigated the incident and concluded Haughton had not breached her bail. She was only involved in the transfer of Canadian Kennel Club registration for the puppy, as she was the previous registered owner. The dog was being cared for by someone else.

Prosecutor Chris Balison noted the SPCA recommended a charge of breach of bail, but the Crown has decided not to proceed with the charge.

Judge Frame told Haughton there is no “wiggle room” in the new conditions. “There are no grey areas, it is straight black and white,” said the judge.

“It is almost impossible,” Haughton replied.

“You will have to make it possible,” Frame said.

Haughton is back in court Dec. 12, for the start of a trial on animal cruelty charges. An earlier set of similar charges stemming from July 2009 will continue next year.

Haughton, 60, has served 75 days in jail in recent months for breaching the terms of bail orders prohibiting her from having “care or control” of pets like cats, dogs and birds.

She is allowed to interact with domestic livestock for the purpose of earning a living. A B.C. Supreme Court judge also granted Haughton permission to possess 20 sheep, one guard dog for the flock and one cat to control mice at her Knutsford ranch house.

Tuesday, November 29, 2011

Towards Accountability

This puppy was among the 24 dogs, 17 of which are eligible for adoption, at the Cape Breton SPCA on Friday. Animals are held for three days before being put up for adoption, in order to give an owner time to locate and claim a lost pet. SPCA staff said that three dogs had been adopted as of 3:30 p.m. on Friday.The Provincial Board of the Nova Scotia SPCA has laid seige to its own Cape Breton branch, located in Sydney. In early November, apparently without much warning, an order went out to the Sydney shelter to shut down. ...

While such disputes between branches are relatively rare, the board's sudden is the most recent of a long list of questionable actions that cast the SPCA in the role of a charity that has forgotten its purpose. Sure, the organization operates shelters around the province that (with the exception of the Metro Shelter) take in any number of stray and unwanted animals to find them new homes. Doubtless they do a lot of good. Although not all of the healthy ones are adopted, by and large it seems that the charity does the best it can.

On a regular basis, however, glaring headlines tell of large-scale SPCA seizures of animals - dogs, cats, horses - from people depicted as hoarders or abusers. "Worst case I've ever seen," claims the SPCA special constable in charge of the seizure. The public's heartstrings and wallets are plucked. Donations pour in, and adoptions are hastily arranged, while the accused are cast in permanent disgrace and face criminal charges.

But the story doesn't always have a happy ending.  

In an alarming number of cases, few or no charges result. Why? Mysteriously, the SPCA lacks sufficient grounds. Charges laid are often dropped later, due to lack of evidence. But that can take months and years. And by that time, the seized animals have long since been sold for adoption, never to be seen again by the hapless owners. Some of the accused are subjected to out-of-court demands to hand over exorbitant sums to the SPCA for the care and keeping of animals that should never have been seized in the first place. Others are given pre-trial conditions banning them from owning or being near animals.

In a particularly bizarre case, after a seizure of dozens of purebred dogs and other animals from her large ranch in BC, a woman was jailed for months for allegedly violating such conditions. But she has yet to be prosecuted on the charges themselves. 

Against the spectre of suffering animals, the principle of "innocent until proven guilty" falls by the wayside. Little attention is given to legalities, let alone outcomes. Nor is it widely known that the SPCA's "special constables" sometimes ride roughshod over legal requirements, failing to do thorough on-site investigations, issue prior warnings to owners, submit truthful information for warrant applications, or improperly carry out seizures.

With an intact reputation as a do-good charity entrusted with the task of law enforcement, courts are loathe to hold the SPCA accountable for such violations of fundamental Charter rights. 

Although it is paid for its work - salaried special constables, shelter managers, and executive directors oversee the work of volunteers - the SPCA is viewed as a welcome aid making untold sacrifices in an age of shrinking government budgets. As a result, animal owners who are falsely accused must bear the burdens of trauma and loss alone. Sometimes, their beloved animals die in the process. Rarely, if ever, do these hapless individuals recover their property or their reputations. Families fall apart, careers are lost.

Across Canada, an epidemic of SPCA abuses goes unnoticed - abuses of the law, abuses of power, abuses of animals (who undergo trauma as well, and sometimes do not recover); abuses of the public's trust. The aim of this blog is to bring this epidemic to light. The information here is factual. Opinions will be clearly differentiated from factual reporting.